‘Chicago Fire’: David Eigenberg Explains Why Herrmann Can’t Take Over for Boden

At the end of Chicago Fire Season 12, Wallace Boden (Eamonn Walker) became Deputy Commissioner, but he knew that in leaving, he needed to have someone replace him. And as it’s become clear over the years, but especially in the finale, the person for that position is Herrmann (David Eigenberg).


After all, in the finale, it was Herrmann who stepped up to remind the others of the lives they did manage to save on a tough call. Herrmann wasn’t sure, but Boden told him he just needed to be himself, the person “who looks out for people, who listens, who always leads with his heart.” But then less than a month after the finale aired, it was reported that a new character will be coming in as chief in a series regular role.

This new battalion chief, potentially named Dom Pascal, “began his career with the CFD but spent the last decade as a chief in Sunny Miami,” according to Deadline. He’s “a cheerful person who works well under pressure, and whose leadership style differs from Boden’s.” There’s also potential for personal drama; he’s estranged from his wife.

But fans probably shouldn’t have been surprised when it was reported that Herrmann won’t be taking over for Boden, as David Eigenberg told TV Insider at the Television Critics’ Association Summer Press Tour. After all, it’s not like Herrmann could have just become battalion chief; he’s currently only a lieutenant.

“The character can’t make a shift to a chief unless we were deep into TV falsehoods,” Eigenberg pointed out. “I’m not going to let him do that. He has to become a captain, and then you got to go through a whole thing. I think that the character might be able to make the transition. I don’t know. Who knows? They may put me in chief and then fire me as a chief. We’ll see.”

As for how Herrmann’s going to feel about this new character coming in, considering what Boden told him he wanted, Eigenberg’s not sure yet. “I know Herrmann is always floating around. His brain is always kind of a little bit whacked out about everything, so we’re just going to see what happens,” he said.

Still, we do expect to see Herrmann stepping up into a leadership role around 51, even if it’s not with an official promotion.

What do you think of someone new coming in? Let us know in the comments section, below.

Related articles

“Chicago P.D. Reruns Rekindle My Heartache: Why Halstead and Upton’s Exit Still Stings”

Chicago P.D. was a wild ride during Season 10 as the Intelligence Unit dealt with the absence of Jay Halstead due to the departure of Jesse Lee…

“How Jay Halstead’s Chicago PD Exit Should Have Been Handled: A Missed Opportunity for a Fitting Farewell”

The idea behind Halstead’s Chicago PD exit arc could have resulted in a compelling exit if NBC was able to execute the storyline differently. For starters, the…

Chicago PD Season 12’s New Character Makes Replacing Hailey Upton Trickier

As Chicago PD approaches its twelfth season, the show is undergoing significant changes, including the departure of a key character and the introduction of a new one….

‘Chicago P.D.’ Season 12 Kicks Off in September: Everything to Know About the Cop Show

During season 11 of the series, fans finally saw Kim Burgess (Marina Squerciati) and Adam Ruzek (Patrick Flueger) get engaged and stay that way. The pair famously…

Chicago Fire, P.D. and Med Teaser Offers a First Look at Dermot Mulroney’s New Chief: ‘Let’s Hit It, Team!’ (Exclusive)

Exclusive First Look: Dermot Mulroney’s New Chief in Chicago Fire, Chicago P.D., and Chicago Med. Fans of the Chicago franchise are in for a treat as Chicago…

The Big Problem Some Chicago Fire Fans Have With The Female Characters’ Stories

“Chicago Fire” — the first of NBC’s “One Chicago” franchise — follows the professional and personal lives of the fictional Firehouse 51 of the Chicago Fire Department, including…