The Subtle Detail In Chicago Fire That Makes The Show Completely Unrealistic

Ever since its debut back in 2012, producer Dick Wolf’s action-drama “Chicago Fire” has attracted millions of die-hard fans each week with its ostensibly realistic portrayal of the first responders working out of the Windy City’s Firehouse 51. As the initial offering in Wolf’s “One Chicago” franchise of procedurals for NBC, the series eventually spun off two equally successful sister shows, with “Chicago P.D.” launching in 2014 and “Chicago Med” following suit a year later. Delivering scorching-hot ratings in its usual Wednesday night primetime slot, the series continues to be one of the hottest properties on network TV (per One Chicago Center).

Presented as a grounded, authentic picture of the high-risk, on-duty lives and off-duty personal challenges of its courageous firefighters and paramedics, the truth is “Chicago Fire” hasn’t always kept every aspect of the series totally fact-based. In this regard, a subtle detail about one vital piece of the firehouse squad’s equipment seems to be utterly unrealistic, at least in the opinion of some veteran real-world firefighters.

The breathing apparatus used in Chicago Fire isn’t the real deal

Presented as a grounded, authentic picture of the high-risk, on-duty lives and off-duty personal challenges of its courageous firefighters and paramedics, the truth is “Chicago Fire” hasn’t always kept every aspect of the series totally fact-based. In this regard, a subtle detail about one vital piece of the firehouse squad’s equipment seems to be utterly unrealistic, at least in the opinion of some veteran real-world firefighters.

The breathing apparatus used in Chicago Fire isn’t the real deal

Forum poster FyredUp wondered, “So what is wth [sic] the funky face pieces on the Scott masks…Those are NOT standard facepieces. The regulator does not lay flat like that at the bottom of the mask… Is this a new mask I haven’t seen yet or something custom made for the show so you can see the actor’s face?” Forum member Chenzo agreed something wasn’t right with the SCBA, saying, “At least I’m not the only one wondering what in hell is up with those face pieces.” Poster FWDbuff attempted to be a bit more charitable about the issue, writing, “…understand that it is a TV show made for entertainment purposes by Hollywood studio-types…” And while producer Wolf would doubtless agree with the later statement regarding entertainment value, this is one subtle but vital detail in “Chicago Fire” that makes the show unrealistic — at least for viewers who seem to have experience charging into actual flaming buildings.

Related articles

“Chicago P.D. Reruns Rekindle My Heartache: Why Halstead and Upton’s Exit Still Stings”

Chicago P.D. was a wild ride during Season 10 as the Intelligence Unit dealt with the absence of Jay Halstead due to the departure of Jesse Lee…

“How Jay Halstead’s Chicago PD Exit Should Have Been Handled: A Missed Opportunity for a Fitting Farewell”

The idea behind Halstead’s Chicago PD exit arc could have resulted in a compelling exit if NBC was able to execute the storyline differently. For starters, the…

Chicago PD Season 12’s New Character Makes Replacing Hailey Upton Trickier

As Chicago PD approaches its twelfth season, the show is undergoing significant changes, including the departure of a key character and the introduction of a new one….

‘Chicago P.D.’ Season 12 Kicks Off in September: Everything to Know About the Cop Show

During season 11 of the series, fans finally saw Kim Burgess (Marina Squerciati) and Adam Ruzek (Patrick Flueger) get engaged and stay that way. The pair famously…

Chicago Fire, P.D. and Med Teaser Offers a First Look at Dermot Mulroney’s New Chief: ‘Let’s Hit It, Team!’ (Exclusive)

Exclusive First Look: Dermot Mulroney’s New Chief in Chicago Fire, Chicago P.D., and Chicago Med. Fans of the Chicago franchise are in for a treat as Chicago…

The Big Problem Some Chicago Fire Fans Have With The Female Characters’ Stories

“Chicago Fire” — the first of NBC’s “One Chicago” franchise — follows the professional and personal lives of the fictional Firehouse 51 of the Chicago Fire Department, including…